Benny’s of Simsbury Menu

Welcome to Benny’s of Simsbury, a remarkable dining experience nestled in the heart of Simsbury, CT. This eatery masterfully blends Mediterranean, New American, and Italian cuisines, creating a menu that caters to various palates. From hearty breakfasts to flavorful lunches, each dish resonates with quality and comfort.

Patrons rave about the expertly crafted Black and Blue Burger, and our standout offering, the lamb beef gyro, is hailed as one of the best in the region. With an inviting atmosphere and attentive service, customers feel right at home while enjoying meals made with care. The versatility of the menu accommodates everyone—from families to those on the go with options like delivery and takeout.

Benny’s is not just a restaurant; it's a community hub, perfect for any occasion, whether a casual brunch or a celebratory dinner.

Eggs Your Way

2 Eggs Any Style

Your choice of style of eggs, toast, and potatoes.

$$9.00

2 Eggs Any Style With Meat

Choice of house made sausage, applewood smoked bacon, Canadian bacon or ham.

$$14.00

2 Eggs Any Style With Turkey Sausage

$$15.95

2 Eggs Any Style With Corned Beef Hash

$$16.95

House Meal With Meat

3 eggs any style served with applewood smoked bacon, house made sausage, ham or Canadian bacon.

$$14.95

House Meal With Corned Beef Hash

3 eggs any style with corned beef hash.

$$17.95

House Meal With Turkey Sausage

3 eggs any style with turkey sausage.

$$16.95

Egg And Cheese Sandwich

$$7.50

Egg, Cheese And Meat Sandwich

Choice of house made sausage, applewood smoked bacon, Canadian bacon, jalapeno bacon, or ham.

$$9.00

The Denver Sandwich

Ham, sausage, peppers, onions and cheese.

$$14.95

The Simsbury Sandwich

Grilled onions, ham, applewood smoked bacon, cheese and chipotle mayo.

$$14.95

The Californian Sandwich

Applewood smoked bacon, tomato, fresh avocado and cheese.

$$14.95

Lox Sandwich

North Atlantic smoked salmon, cream cheese, onions, tomatoes, cucumbers and capers.

$$16.00

Morning Sandwiches

Omeletes

Caprese Omelet

3 eggs with baby spinach, pan seared basil, local tomatoes and fresh mozzarella cheese finished with balsamic glazed.

$$16.95

Spinach Omelet

Baby spinach, mixed mushrooms, onions and cheese.

$$17.00

California Omelet

Applewood smoked bacon, tomato, fresh avocado and cheese. Served with your choice of bread and home fries or shredded potato. Egg whites for additional charge. Substitute with English muffin for additional charge or gluten free for additional charge.

$$16.95

Primavera Omelet

3 egg whites with olive oil, tomato, bell pepper, mixed mushrooms, arugula, scallion served with English muffin and cup of seasonal fresh fruit.

$$17.95

Meat Lovers Omelet

House made sausage, applewood smoked bacon, ham and cheese.

$$17.50

Athenian Scramble

Mixed mushrooms, olives and feta cheese.

$$16.95

Heart Healthy Scramble

Egg whites, baby spinach, garlic, peppers and Swiss cheese. Served with cup of fruit.

$$17.95

Western Scramble

Ham, peppers, onions and cheese.

$$16.95

Scrambles

Breakfast Etc.

Mexican Burrito

Scrambled eggs, jalapenos, onions, tomatoes, applewood smoked bacon, pepper jack cheese wrapped with choice of your tortilla bread.

$$15.95

The Benny

Scrambled eggs, lamb or chicken gyro meat, onions, peppers, cheddar cheese wrapped with choice of your tortilla bread.

$$17.00

Vegetable Burrito

Scrambled eggs, mushrooms, onions, peppers, baby spinach, tomatoes and feta cheese wrapped with choice of your tortilla bread.

$$14.95

Craft Your Own Omelet

$$15.95

Craft Your Own Scramble

$$15.95

Craft Your Own Omelets and Scrambles

Benedicts

Traditional Benedict

2 poached eggs, Canadian bacon and house made hollandaise sauce on an English muffin.

$$16.00

Simsbury Benedict

2 poached eggs, bacon, ham, onions and house made hollandaise sauce on a croissant.

$$16.00

Irish Benedict

2 poached eggs, corned beef hash and house made hollandaise sauce on an English muffin.

$$16.00

Florentine Benedict

2 poached eggs, baby spinach and fresh dill hollandaise sauce on an English muffin.

$$16.00

2 Buttermilk Pancakes

Add strawberries, bananas, chocolate chips or walnuts for an additional charge.

$$12.95

Buttermilk Waffle

Add strawberries, bananas, chocolate chips or walnuts for an additional charge.

$$9.95

Cinnamon Roll French Toast

3 pieces of spiced cinnamon swirl with cream cheese icing.

$$14.95

2 Slices Of Challah French Toast

Add strawberries, bananas, chocolate chips or walnuts for an additional charge.

$$12.95

Cobbler

2 pancakes filled with fresh apples or fresh peaches with oatmeal, cinnamon and brown sugar.

$$14.95

Hungry Man

2 pancakes or 2 french toast or 1 waffle, 2 eggs any style and choice of applewood smoked bacon, ham or house made sausage.

$$15.95

Maple Plates

Avocado Toasts

Californian Avocado Toast

2 eggs served sunny side up over our house multigrain avocado toast with tomatoes, topped with Amish crumbled blue cheese.

$$12.95

Bennys Avocado Toast

2 eggs sunny side up with crumbled crispy applewood smoked bacon over avocado spread multigrain toast.

$$13.95

Gritz

$$7.95

Fresh Fruit Parfait With Greek Yogurt

$$10.95

Seasonal Mixed Fruit

$$7.95

Oatmeal

Add raisins, blueberries, strawberries or bananas for an additional charge.

$$9.95

Sensibles

Breakfast Sides

1 Egg

$$4.00

2 Eggs

$$5.50

Side Of Corned Beef Hash

$$7.00

Side Of Canadian Bacon

$$7.00

Side Of Applewood Smoked Bacon

$$7.50

Side Of Smoked Ham

$$7.00

Side Of Sausage Links

$$7.00

Side Sausage Patty

$$8.00

Side Of Turkey Sausage

$$9.00

Shredded Potatoes

$$4.00

Side Of Home Fries

$$7.00

Loaded Home Fries

Made with onions, cheese and bacon.

$$10.00

Rye Bread

$$4.95

Whole Wheat Bread

$$4.95

White Bread

$$4.95

Bagel

Everything, onion or plain.

$$6.00

Challah

$$5.00

Brioche

$$5.00

Muffin

Blueberry or corn.

$$5.95

Croissant

$$5.50

English Muffin

$$5.50

Sourdough Bread

$$5.00

Ciabatta Bread

$$5.50

Gluten Free Toast

$$6.00

Breads

Breakfast Kids Menu

Kids Woody

Cheese omelet with a cup of fresh fruit.

$$10.95

Kids WallE

1 pancake or French toast with 2 slices of bacon. Add fruit for additional charge.

$$11.00

Kids Nemo

1 egg any style with 2 slices of bacon, choice of potato and bread.

$$10.95

Wings

8 wings tossed in your choice of sauce and served with our own bleu cheese dressing.

$$17.00

Mozzarella Sticks

7 breaded mozzarella sticks served with a side of homemade marinara sauce.

$$14.00

Hummus Plate

House made hummus with carrots, celery, Kalamata olives, tomatoes and red onion, served with warm pita bread. Add beef and lamb gyro or chicken gyro for an additional charge.

$$16.00

Chicken Tenders

5 breaded, all white meat boneless chicken served with choice of honey mustard or BBQ sauce.

$$15.00

Meatballs

Our house made meatballs in our homemade marinara sauce.

$$12.00

Arancini

3 house made rice balls stuffed with fresh mozzarella cheese and fried to perfection, topped with our house made marinara sauce.

$$16.00

Appetizers

Soups and Salads

New England Clam Chowder

$$9.00

Tomato And Basil Soup

$$8.00

Greek Salad

Fresh greens, tomatoes, cucumbers, onions, Kalamata olives, carrots, dolma and feta cheese tossed in our Greek dressing.

$$16.00

Chicken And Apple Salad

Fresh greens, apples, Brie cheese, tomatoes, cucumbers, candied walnuts and carrots in our apple vinaigrette dressing.

$$17.00

Beet Salad

Fresh beets, roasted over a bed of mixed greens with heirloom tomatoes, burrata cheese and tossed in our house balsamic glazed reduction.

$$16.00

Chef Salad

Ham, turkey, Swiss cheese, hard boiled egg, tomatoes, cucumbers, onions, carrots and olives in our own take on a creamy French dressing.

$$17.00

Cobb Salad

Applewood bacon, chicken, cucumbers, tomatoes, onions, fresh avocado, hard boiled egg, Gorgonzola cheese over mixed greens dressed with our Dijon mustard vinaigrette.

$$17.00

Caprese Salad

Fresh mozzarella cheese with sliced tomatoes and fresh basil, drizzled with extra virgin olive oil and a savory balsamic reduction served over a bed of lemon vinaigrette dressed arugula.

$$16.00

Create Your Own Grinder

$$15.00

Create Your Own Wrap

$$13.00

Create Your Own Grinders and Wraps

Gyros

Gyro Combo

Layers of lamb, beef and chicken gyro wrapped in your choice of pita bread or ciabatta bread with onions.

$$17.00

Classic Gyro

Beef or chicken gyro served on ciabatta bread and topped with cheddar cheese.

$$17.00

Falafel Crisp

Crisp falafel wrapped in pita bread with onions, lettuce, tomatoes, hummus and Tzatziki sauce.

$$18.00

Classic Burger

Angus beef burger topped with lettuce, tomatoes and red onions. Add cheese for an additional charge.

$$16.00

Cheddar Bacon Burger

Angus beef burger topped Applewood bacon, lettuce, tomatoes, red onions and chipotle mayo.

$$16.95

BBQ Burger

Crispy onion rings, BBQ sauce, lettuce, tomatoes and cheddar cheese.

$$16.95

The Chicken And The Pig

Grilled chicken breast with applewood bacon, house made ranch dressing and cheddar cheese.

$$16.95

Roasted Pork Sandwich

Braised pork, jalapeno bacon, Swiss cheese, pickled cabbage slaw and our chipotle and herb aioli.

$$17.95

Black And Bleu Burger

Cajun seared Angus beef burger topped with blue cheese and frizzled onions.

$$15.95

Bennys Burger

Caramelized onions, mushrooms, lettuce, tomatoes and Swiss cheese.

$$16.95

The Chickpea Burger

House made falafel patty, layered with hummus, lettuce, tomato, onion and tzatziki sauce. Add avocado for an additional charge.

$$17.00

The Italian Chicken Sandwich

Chicken with fresh pesto, lettuce, tomato and provolone cheese.

$$16.00

The Famous Bennys Reuben Sandwich

Home made fresh corned beef with Swiss cheese, sauerkraut and house made Russian dressing on fresh rye bread.

$$16.00

Sandwiches, Burgers, Etc.

Create Your Own Pizza

Create Your Own Pizza

Tomato sauce and mozzarella.

$$16.00

White Clam Pizza

Clams, olive oil, garlic, pecorino Romano cheese and fresh herbs.

$$19.00

Meat Lovers Pizza

Hamburger, sausage, bacon, pepperoni, marinara sauce and mozzarella cheese.

$$20.00

Vegetable Pizza

Broccoli, olives, mushrooms, onions, peppers and mozzarella cheese.

$$15.00

Bennys Gyro Pizza

Chicken, gyro lamb and beef, onions, peppers, fresh marinara, mozzarella cheese and a drizzle of tzatziki.

$$21.00

Chicken Pesto Pizza

Chicken cutlet, fresh basil pesto and fresh mozzarella cheese.

$$18.00

Buffalo Chicken Pizza

Grilled chicken tossed in Buffalo sauce with blue cheese dressing, blue cheese and mozzarella cheese.

$$19.00

BBQ Chicken Pizza

BBQ chicken cutlet, marinara sauce and mozzarella cheese, caramelized onions and roasted red peppers.

$$18.00

Mediterranean Pizza

Sundried tomato, garlic, onion, feta cheese, pesto, herbs and red sauce.

$$18.00

Specialty Pizza

Lunch Kids Menu

Kids Shrek

3 chicken tenders served with french fries and choice of BBQ or honey mustard sauce.

$$11.95

Kids Mr. Incredible

Grilled cheese served with french fries.

$$10.50

Kids Kung Fu Panda

Penne pasta with cheese sauce.

$$11.00

Kids Boss Baby

Penne pasta served with butter or marinara sauce. Add meatball or sausage for an additional charge.

$$10.95

Kids Trolls

3 mozzarella sticks with french fries and marinara sauce.

$$11.00

Cappuccino

$$9.00

Espresso

$$6.00

Coffee

$$5.85

Tea

$$5.85

Hot Chocolate

$$6.50

Milk

$$5.50

Chocolate Milk

$$6.00

Juice

Orange, apple, cranberry, or tomato.

$$6.00

Freshly Squeezed Orange Juice

$$7.95

20 Oz. Coke Products

$$6.50

Fountain Soda

$$6.00

Bottled Juices

$$5.85

Beverages